Thursday, February 5th, 2009...7:03 am

Ime Udoka: What Could Have Been

Jump to Comments
Ime Udoka

Ime Udoka

A 52 point triple double can take your mind to weird places. It has me thinking about Ime Udoka.

When Ime Udoka arrived in San Antonio there were suggestions that he was Bruce Bowen’s heir apparent. The Portland coaching staff often touted Udoka as their top defender and LeBron James once listed him as a difficult one on one match up. And then, of course, there was the legendary Gabe Muoneke account of Ime as the Afr-I-Can who can kill his Fu-fu. The Blazers coaching staff was fond of describing Udoka in this way:

Regarded by his coaches as Portland’s best perimeter defender, Udoka has drawn the toughest assignment in most every game. In the first 40 days of the season, for example, Trail Blazer Coach Nate McMillan called on Ime to defend some of the NBA’s greatest offensive threats, namely LeBron James, Kobe Bryant, Paul Pierce, Joe Johnson, Vince Carter, Lamar Odom, Michael Redd, Grant Hill and Rashard Lewis.

“They’re all really tough assignments, ” Ime says, “but what I appreciated about it is that guarding them reaffirms for me that I have been prepared to play in this league. Yes, they’re great players, but I haven’t felt overwhelmed in playing them.”

“What I like about Ime’s defense,” says McMillan, “is that he doesn’t fall for a lot of head fakes and shake and bakes. He’s learned sound defensive fundamentals,” such as keeping his feet on the floor, moving quickly laterally, and keeping the player with the ball in front of him.

Blazer assistant coach Maurice Lucas likes Udoka’s versatility. Lucas told the Portland Tribune’s Kerry Eggers, “It’s surprised me, the multiple positions he can play. His basketball IQ is real high.”

Udoka has hard time finding the court these days, and he was upstaged by D-league standout Malik Hairston on Tuesday night. He’s averaging 13 minutes a game this season (which seems high to me), a 7 minute dip on his career average. After Tuesday night’s contest, the rabid contigency of the Spurs faithful were calling for Malik Hairston to replace Udoka in the depth chart.

What does this have to do with LeBron James?

Not that James can be defended, because we know he can’t. But when Udoka first signed with the Spurs I had visions of Bowen and Udoka tag-teaming to slow players like Kobe Bryant and LeBron James in the conference and league championship rounds. I no longer maintain such visions. Bruce Bowen has been replaced by Michael Finley in the starting line up; Ime Udoka is always teetering on the brink of a DNP-CD. Neither player has enough offense to warrant long minutes, and both players have lost a little something on defense. This last point is often overstated with regard to Bowen, who is still capable of great defense in spot duty. But since his arrival in San Antonio, Udoka has been more effective as a small ball four than lock down wing. And although I don’t think Hairston will replace him in the rotation, I’m confident such a move would not signal a drastic drop in production. Hairston, ironically, has more promise as a swing defender.

In other words, I’ve always feared that players like Bryant and James could take any given game during a playoff series. In past seasons, however, my confidence in the Spurs ability to slow these players was bolstered by the Bruce Bowen option. This is no longer the case. The Spurs will have to find another way around the aforementioned scoring greats if they are to win a title this season.

4 Comments

  • “What Could Have Been” is the perfect title for your post. That’s exactly the first thing that crosses my mind when I watch Udoka play these days. It wasn’t too long ago that Udoka’s 3-pointers had the fame of coming in timely fashion, and it didn’t hurt my eyes to see him attempting to score. (Aah, the hours spent typing “Fatality!” in PTR… those halcyon days…)

    Sometimes us fans who watch most of the Spurs’ games lack the perspective to really notice when a player starts slipping. It would be interesting to retroactively do the research, and try to pinpoint as accurately as possible the exact moment Pop gave up on him. (For example, we all believe Pop had enough of Beno during the 2005 playoffs when he couldn’t take the ball past the halfcourt line without turning it over.)

    If such moment exists. This season he has been pretty consistent with his suckage.

  • Since his arrival, I have always expect Ime to live up to the expectations I had by reading about him. I imagined him as a Bowen-like defender and corner shooter but as time goes by he keeps lowering them. Don’t get me wrong, I like him and I still think he can be a great asset in particular situations, it’s just that I cannot longer see him as being a big part of the team.

  • Great article, I for one, just refuse to admit Ime cant contribute a bit in the playoffs in the situation you describe. He’s no scorer like, gulp, Bowen, that’s just not a realistic expectation, but cool someone hot? Keep hope alive!
    hyped free agent? Bowen came to us the same way. Part of it may be Tim and Manu are older, and can’t make up for the Avery type non scorer player on the floor anymore.

  • I can’t understate the importance of the Spurs finding a replacement for Bowen. I remember when Udoka was signed, the coaching staff and media had expectations of him easing into Bowen’s shoes. Bowen is really a niche player that fit in perfectly with the Spurs system. He was a lock down defender who spaced the floor, showed hustle and grit, and could get into opponent’s heads. I, as a Nuggets fan, watched Bowen give Carmelo fits for years, but over the past year and a half, Bowen has looked like a stiff body that belongs on the end of the bench.

    Udoka just isn’t going to fill his role. The spurs will need to look elsewhere and find someone more physical. Finley needs replacing as well - soon. If the Spurs were somehow able to trade for Caron Butler and keep the big three intact, thats 3-5 more guaranteed years of contention.

    At this point, as much as it pains me to say this, Malik Hairston looked like a more viable replacement for what Bowen brought to the table than Udoka.

Leave a Reply