The shot that should’ve been historic


Yesterday, Mike Monroe of the San Antonio Express-News wrote about the Thunder’s Derek Fisher and the obvious bad memories that arise for Spurs fans when Fisher’s name is mentioned. I probably don’t need to remind you about one of the more famous shots in NBA Playoff history. It’s a shot that, to this day, I can’t watch without my soul dying a little, Charlie Murphy be damned.

What’s fascinating, and disheartening, to me is that what would’ve been one of the more famous shots in NBA playoff history is practically forgotten because of some craftiness on Fisher’s part and a clock operator with a slow trigger finger. Tim Duncan hit what one could argue was a more difficult shot than the .04 shot that Fisher hit and unfortunately it’s rarely mentioned because of the events that followed.

The shots came in Game 5 of the Spurs’ second round series against the Lakers in 2004. San Antonio swept the Memphis Grizzlies in the first round (these were the days before Pau Gasol was traded to the Lakers, but that’s a gut punch for another day) and went into the series with the Lakers holding home court advantage. After taking the first two at home, the Spurs dropped Games 3 and 4 in Los Angeles.

That set the table for that fateful Game 5. The fifth game of a series tied at 2-2 essentially decides who will win the series, at least based on percentages. Back in the days of the Spurs’ dominant defense, San Antonio outscored the Lakers 18-10 in the fourth quarter in the lead up to the final two possessions. Remember the days when the Spurs scoring 73 points in a game was a thing? These days that’s a mid-third quarter score. Anyways, the Spurs lost every quarter heading into the fourth and it took a Herculean 18 points in the first 11:54 of the fourth quarter to have what was thought to be a last second shot.

Manu Ginobili was the inbounder on this play. Like the defense-first mentality of the Spurs, the eight man rotation Gregg Popovich ran with at the time seems archaic today. Rasho Nesterovic and Hedo Turkoglu started alongside Tim Duncan, Tony Parker and Bruce Bowen. Along with Ginobili, Devin Brown and Robert Horry were the only three players to come off the bench in the game. Malik Rose, Kevin Willis and Ron Mercer (!) were among the reserves not used in Game 5. And Mario Elie was an assistant coach. I love that team, even if for the sheer randomness of it.

Heading into the sideline out of bounds play with 5.4 seconds left, Duncan had 19 points and 21 rebounds to go along with four blocks. He also had a uncharacteristic seven turnovers. Ginobili faked a pass to Devin Brown cutting to the corner and inbounded the ball to Duncan near the elbow, with Shaq closely guarding Duncan. Ginobili faked like he was going to rub off Duncan towards the center of the floor, then cut the other direction towards the low block, taking Kobe Bryant with him.

As Ginobili runs Bryant off on Duncan, the Big Fundamental faces up on Shaq and attacks to his left, towards the top of the key. Two dribbles later, Duncan takes a very un-fundamental shot ,essentially a floater from the top of the key, fading to his left. It hits nothing but the back of the rim on its way through the hoop.

It really can’t be understated how difficult of a shot that was. In fact, it was eerily similar to the shot that followed from Fisher. The two major differences being that Fisher had even more of a time crunch than Duncan had, but TD had a full-bodied Shaq pressed up against him. This wasn’t the out of shape Shaq that refused to close out on a Tim Duncan 3-pointer, this was the in-his-prime Shaq that was actually engaged on one-on-one perimeter defense for a play. And Duncan still hit it.

For a few moments, we thought it was over. Spurs fans had watched years earlier as the team couldn’t defend the franchise’s first NBA title because of a Tim Duncan knee injury. We watched as the Lakers captured three titles in a row, two of those in which the Lakers trampled the Spurs en route to the Finals. The Spurs finally overcame the Shaq and Kobe Lakers again in 2003, a run that featured a 110-82 smashing in the clinching Game 6 of the second round in Los Angeles. This was going to be the year the Spurs repeated as champions.

There was no way the Lakers could score with .4 seconds left without some sort of backdoor play that resulted in a lob at the basket. That’s what I thought. Getting the ball anywhere out on the perimeter was going to take too long. There wasn’t enough time for a catch-and-shoot. Or so we thought.

Long story short: hate you Derek Fisher.

(Note: I recommend turning off this video at the 1:25 mark if you want to sleep without crying this weekend. Also note Doc Rivers doing the analysis in this game)

  • rkfan1012

    That video…horrifying to this day.

  • Len

    I know exactly where I was watching this when it happened. It’s like the OJ verdict, when Reagan got shot and the for the older crowd, when JFK was assassinated.

    For all of the Spurs success, this is the biggest cross to bear for the team and us fans.

  • Patrick

    It’s worse than watching the Zapruder film.

  • Len

    Pop should have put a man on the in bounder. I think it’s the biggest blunder in Pop’s magnificent career. And I wouldn’t be surprised if it’s something that drives him to do every little thing he can to win, i.e. hack-a-whoever

  • TheRealDirtyP1

    I forget. Why wasn’t Bruce in the game? Did he foul out?

  • Jimbo

    Shot shouldn’t have counted. The time-keeper should have been taken out and shot for that screwup.

  • Bob

    It reminds me of how good Phil Jackson was. He was also really good at defending inbound plays. I think he liked to put a long and quick player on the inbounder to make it a difficult pass.

  • Ray Briggs

    I’ll go to my grave KNOWING that shot should not have counted. The time keeper really screwed the Spurs entire season there.

  • idahospur

    I was out of the country when this happened. I would’ve had a broken TV if I wasn’t.

  • Vermont Spurs Fan

    This is the shot that caused the posthumous rule change. You can no longer shoot with .04 only tip it in.

    Worst mistake in the history of officiating? Probably not, but the argument in favor of this as the single worst moment is that it is so obvious.

    No way to go back and undo this? Sweetest revenge was the beautiful, beautiful Pistons taking the Lakers down and then the following year they were dismantled. I will always love the Pistons for that bit of justice.

  • Actually

    Vermont Spurs Fan,

    Turn to page 59. Educate yourself. Thanks.

  • David

    My sad story about this… I’m in a hotel bar next to Disneyland for a conference watching that game. Me… the only Spurs fan… not a lot of cheering on my part until Timmy hits that shot at which point I scream for the first time… only to be crushed by that shot… I’m with you … a little bit of my soul dies every time I see that.

  • Jimbo

    Vermont, you might be thinking of the Trent Tucker rule (I think that was the name of that Bulls player).

    And this is only the second worst call of all time- the worst ever was Scottie Pippen’s “foul” against Hubert Davis in 1994. Still bitter about it . . .

  • Bankshot21

    I am shocked no one ever points out the blatant hand check foul on Shaquille. It should have been an and 1. Duncan would have subsequently missed the free throw intentionally and we may be talking about TD getting number 6 this year and not 5.

  • Pingback: Western Conference Finals Game 1: San Antonio Spurs 101, Oklahoma City Thunder 98 | 48 Minutes of Hell()

  • TheRealDirtyP1

    I’m glad Fisher played 33 minutes and that his final game as a player was against the Spurs. It’s amazing he only ended up with 4 fouls. I don’t like Fisher, never will, and it’s not just because of what he did against the Spurs. He screwed the Jazz over by using his daughter’s health issues as a reason he needed to leave, and then turned around and signed with the Lakers, who were even farther away from his daughter’s doctors than being in Utah. And it doesn’t end there, he did the same thing to the Mavs. He told them he wanted to be closer to his kids in LA and asked Cuban to release him and he ends up in…..OKC. The guy is a liar and manipulator, and you don’t even need to know the off the court stuff, just watch his over exaggeration on fouls.
    Unless Derek Fisher cures cancer, I will always dislike him.

  • Pingback: Death, Taxes and Spurs Fandom | Bro Jackson()